Updated (October, 2012): Compare the Nikon D5200 vs Pentax K-5 II

Pentax K-5

Winner
Pentax K-5

91

vs

Nikon D5100

71

Nikon D5100

Runner-up
     
 

Reasons to buy the Pentax K-5

Overall image quality
Great image quality
82.0
Movie format
Full HD
1080p @ 25fps
Dynamic range
Wide dynamic range
14.1 EV
Viewfinder size
Large viewfinder
0.60x
 

Reasons to buy the Nikon D5100

Movie format
Full HD
1080p @ 30fps
Screen flips out
Flip-out screen
Great for movies
Sensor size
Large sensor
APS-C 23.6x15.6mm
HDR
In-camera HDR
Combines multiple exposures
 
Differences | Recommendations | Cast your vote | Similarities | Competitors | Appearance | Discussion

differences

Advantages of the Nikon D5100

Report a correction
Supports 24p Supports 24p Yes vs No
Help
Get that real film feel
Autofocus Video autofocus Contrast detection vs None
Help
Automatically focuses shooting video
Lens availability Much more lenses available 205 lenses vs 109 lenses
Help
Around 90% more lenses available
Screen flips out Has a flip-out screen Yes vs No
Help
Flip-out screens can be helpful when composing tricky shots or taking movies
Movie format Higher frame rate movies 1080p @ 30fps vs 1080p @ 25fps
Help
Both shoot Full HD (1080p) video, but D5100 does so at a higher frame rate
Lowest price Significantly cheaper $370.00 vs $729.95
Help
The best price we've seen is $360 cheaper (around 50% less)
Weight Significantly lighter 560 g vs 740 g
Help
More than 20% lighter
Startup delay Slightly less startup delay 500 ms vs 600 ms
Help
Around 20% less delay when turning on
Nikon D5100 Learn more about
the Nikon D5100

Advantages of the Pentax K-5

Report a correction
Image stabilization Image stabilization Sensor shift vs None
Help
Helps eliminate blur caused by small camera movements
Shutter lag Much less shutter lag 104 ms vs 273 ms
Help
2.6x less delay when taking photos
Weather sealed Weather sealed Yes vs No
Help
Sealed to shoot in the rain
Viewfinder size Significantly larger viewfinder 0.60x vs 0.51x
Help
Around 40% larger viewfinder
Continuous shooting Shoots significantly faster 7 fps vs 4 fps
Help
Around 80% faster continuous shooting
Cross type focus points Significantly more cross-type focus points 9 vs 1
Help
Grab focus in difficult situations
Light sensitivity (boost) Better boost ISO 51,200 ISO vs 25,600 ISO
Help
The K-5's boost ISO is 1 f-stop better
Viewfinder coverage Significantly better viewfinder coverage 100% vs 95%
Help
Around 10% better viewfinder coverage
Dynamic range More dynamic range 14.1 EV vs 13 EV
Help
1.1 f-stops more dynamic range
Overall image quality Slightly better image quality 82.0 vs 80.0
Help
Almost the same
Viewfinder Has a pentaprism viewfinder Pentaprism vs Pentamirror
Help
Pentaprism viewfinders are typically brighter
Light sensitivity Better maximum light sensitivity 12,800 ISO vs 6,400 ISO
Help
The K-5's maximum light sensitivity is 1 f-stop better
Battery life Longer battery life 740 shots vs 660 shots
Help
More than 10% more shots per battery charge
Size Smaller 130x96x72 mm vs 127x96x78 mm
Help
Around 10% smaller
Thickness Significantly thinner 2.9" vs 3.1"
Help
Around 10% thinner
Color depth Better color depth 23.7 bits vs 23.5 bits
Help
Distinguishes 0.2 more bits of color
Fastest shutter speed Much faster max shutter speed 1/8000s vs 1/4000s
Help
2x faster max shutter speed
Sensor size Slightly larger sensor APS-C 23.6x15.7mm vs APS-C 23.6x15.6mm
Help
Almost the same
Pentax K-5 Learn more about
the Pentax K-5
vs

recommendations

Which camera do we recommend? Relative to the best recent entry-level DSLRs, and ignoring price

Snapsort Recommends
Nikon D5100 Nikon D5100 71
Retailer
    Style
      Color
        You save

        vs

        91 Pentax K-5 Pentax K-5
        Retailer
          Style
            Color
              You save

              similarities

              Compared to recent entry-level DSLRs

              Common Strengths Common Weaknesses
              Low light performance Relatively low noise at high ISO Help
              D5100:1,183 ISO
              K-5:1,162 ISO
              Overall image quality Good image quality Help
              D5100:80.0
              K-5:82.0
              Sensor size Large sensors Help
              D5100:APS-C 23.6x15.6mm
              K-5:APS-C 23.6x15.7mm
              External mic jack Have external mic jacks Help
              Record higher quality audio with a microphone
              True resolution Capture low resolution images Help
              16.1 MP
              Panorama Neither camera stitches together panoramas Help
              You could stitch photos in post
              Focus points Few focus points Help
              11
              Autofocus Lacks video autofocus Help
              D5100:Contrast detection
              K-5:None
              Movie format Full HD (1080p) video Help
              D5100:1080p @ 30fps
              K-5:1080p @ 25fps

              dxomark

              DXOMark

              competitors

              Shared Competitors

              Advantages

              Disadvantages

              Nikon D3200

              Nikon D3200

              Entry-level DSLR

              $597 - $656 body only

              $477 with 18-55mm lens

              True resolution Takes much higher resolution photos
              Fastest shutter speed Has a slower max shutter speed
              Thickness Is thicker
              Canon Rebel T3i

              Canon Rebel T3i

              Entry-level DSLR

              $480 - $774 body only

              $200 - $617 with 18-55mm lens

              True resolution Takes slightly higher resolution photos
              Lowest price Is slightly less expensive
              Fastest shutter speed Has a slower max shutter speed
              Thickness Is thicker
              Nikon D5200

              Nikon D5200

              Entry-level DSLR

              $597 - $647 body only

              $544 - $747 with 18-55mm lens

              Movie format Records higher quality movies
              True resolution Takes much higher resolution photos
              Fastest shutter speed Has a slower max shutter speed
              Lowest price Is slightly more expensive
              Nikon D90

              Nikon D90

              Entry-level DSLR

              $575 - $629 body only

              $830 - $976 with 18-105mm lens

              Battery life Has a slightly longer battery life
              Built-in focus motor Has a built-in focus motor
              Fastest shutter speed Has a slower max shutter speed
              Lowest price Is slightly more expensive
              Nikon D5300

              Nikon D5300

              Entry-level DSLR

              $720 - $747 body only

              $847 with 18-55mm lens

              Low light performance Is slightly less noisy at high ISO
              Movie format Records higher quality movies
              Fastest shutter speed Has a slower max shutter speed
              Lowest price Is significantly more expensive
              Nikon D7000

              Nikon D7000

              Entry-level DSLR

              $701 - $840 body only

              $913 - $1,150 with 18-105mm lens

              Battery life Has a significantly longer battery life
              Focus points Has much more focus points
              Lowest price Is significantly more expensive
              Thickness Is thicker
              Nikon D7100

              Nikon D7100

              Entry-level DSLR

              $1,097 - $1,147 body only

              $1,394 - $1,397 with 18-140mm lens

              Movie format Records higher quality movies
              Screen size Has a significantly larger screen
              Lowest price Is much more expensive
              Thickness Is thicker

              Nikon D5100 Competitors

              Advantages

              Disadvantages

              Nikon D3300

              Nikon D3300

              Entry-level DSLR

              $597 with 18-55mm lens

              Movie format Higher frame rate movies
              Low light performance Lower noise at high ISO
              Startup delay Much more startup delay
              HDR Lacks in-camera HDR
              Nikon D3100

              Nikon D3100

              Entry-level DSLR

              $390 - $427 with 18-55mm lens

              Size Smaller
              Thickness Significantly thinner
              Overall image quality Significantly worse image quality
              Screen resolution Much lower resolution screen

              Pentax K-5 Competitors

              Advantages

              Disadvantages

              Pentax K-3

              Pentax K-3

              Entry-level DSLR

              $988 - $1,197 body only

              $1,200 - $1,337 with 18-55mm lens

              Supports 24p Supports 24p
              Light sensitivity Better maximum light sensitivity
              Battery life Shorter battery life
              Overall image quality Slightly worse image quality
              Pentax K-50

              Pentax K-50

              Entry-level DSLR

              $437 - $498 body only

              $526 - $547 with 18-55mm lens

              Supports 24p Supports 24p
              Light sensitivity Better maximum light sensitivity
              External mic jack Lacks an external mic jack
              Battery life Significantly shorter battery life
              Pentax K-5 II

              Pentax K-5 II

              Entry-level DSLR

              $700 - $714 body only

              $1,049 - $1,187 with 18-55mm lens

              Low light performance Slightly lower noise at high ISO
              Battery life Significantly longer battery life
              Shutter lag Significantly more shutter lag
              Weight Slightly heavier

              appearance

              Nikon D5100 Pentax K-5
              Nikon D5100 Pentax K-5
              Nikon D5100 Pentax K-5

              discussion

              Nikon D5100
              D5100
              Nikon

              Report a correction
              Pentax K-5
              K-5
              Pentax

              Report a correction

              Showing 6 comments

              anonymous (5:31 PM, August 25, 2012)
              please remove the popularity point on each of comparison. we buy camera for the image quality, not the popularity. if it needed, you can put it as additional information
               
              enterco (6:05 AM, June 21, 2012)
              D5100 can't be compared with K-5, they only share image quality. On the ergonomics side, the K-5 is a winner by far. What about the D5100 which can't use 'D' lenses without manual focus? K-5 can shoot with high speed sync, can control multiple flashes, can be operated with one hand, etc.
               
              Chicago painter (7:28 PM, November 13, 2011)
              What is the point to compare cameras for $700 and $1200. It's like to compare BMW 5 and Chevy Malibu. 30G vs 60G.....
              I agree with Sdick. If you spend 700 for body you won't spend 30 000 for all available lenses. 
               
              Sdick (11:21 AM, October 18, 2011)
              K-5 wins in almost any category--except for popularity, # of lenses (how many do I need?) and some of the video convenience features.  I'm probably not like most here, but I'm interested in a DSLR for taking great still pictures.  I won't need it to connect to the internet, do FB, make cel phone calls or play 3D video games.  And if I'm going to do anything more than "dabble" in videography, I'll get a good video camera--to which there aren't any DSLR's at any price that compare.  

              I also find the bias and skew of this site  to be kind of cheap.  Brand "X" might have 50 gazillion lenses, and "Y" has only 30.  I only need/want 3, so am I really disadvantaged to choose those three lenses from 30?  "X" is more popular--save it for the MA pageant.  I think both these cams are great pieces of engineering and very capable for producing excellent photos.  The K-5 wins hands-down for durability, backwards compatibility of lenses, and slightly less-hands-down on some of the issues that will affect image quality.  It admittedly does lose out as a pinch-hitter of a video camera--though both of these are pinch-hitters in this category in my opinion.  And the K-5 price is a bit higher--that generally doesn't stop the serious photog who makes a living.  I just wish Pentax would have left off some of the bells-n-whistles they stuck into this one.  Shame on ALL the brands for some of the bandwagons they jump on.  Toy camera?  Miniature effect? How serious do you take yourselves?  And why do you look for/want/need some of these worthless gadgets on a serious machine?  Buy the toy camera for $6 on e-bay and get the "real" effect.  Give me a great lens or two, durability, good metering, PASM and excellent picture quality.  Affordability would also be nice.  I don't need much else.  The Sigma SD-1 just about knocked it out of the park in my books--until I saw the price.
               
              Avatar for JeanMarcDufourq JeanMarcDufourq (5:27 AM, August 02, 2011)
              I agree. This entire site sways towards Nikon; that, or there comparison algorithm does not work correctly.
               
              eikit nahuj (8:25 PM, July 29, 2011)
              and again.. Entry level Nikon is as good as semi pro pentax. Come on,stop this BS. Just tell you are Nikon fans and thats it. Or go ant compare Nikon D40 against K-5 and write that D40 is much better camera, that would be no surprise because all you can write is just how nikon is good and how pentax is awful